A NewsChannel 3 investigation reveals that Zollicoffer did time for distributing marijuana in Chesterfield five years ago, and Newport News court records show he was found guilty for credit card fraud in 2007.
Sources close to the group say the 29-year-old was one of the group's leaders.
Other students who were hazed by the group say Portsmouth native Marvell Edmondson and Williamsburg native Jauwan Holmes drowned during the group's initiation ritual. Seven students were were told to link arms and cross the Appomatox River.
The source also said that 35-year-old Mackey was another of the group's leaders. Court records reveal he's facing petit larceny charges for an incident earlier this year in Petersburg. Chesterfield records show he was found guilty of petit larceny in 2004.
The source said the men charged with hazing claimed the Men of Honor group was a legitimate campus organization, but they now believe the group says it was a scam aimed at recruiting freshmen to promote off-campus parties.
The source said the group started back in 2005 and members would approach VSU students with promises that membership could be lucrative.